Thoughts for My People

An advantage but not a necessity

There is a question I get asked often from my people that I do not quite know how to answer.

 

Firstly, I have never really understood why they ask it… it is like being asked why I breathe or why we cannot fly. Secondly, I am not sure what kind of answer they are expecting to get – do they want technical advice, or do they just want encouragement? And thirdly, I feel that the question is missing the point altogether, so I cannot see how any of my answers will truly help them. The question?

 

“How do you become fluent in English?”

 

Although I always spoke my mother tongue at home (my parents were very strict about it), I spent most of my formative years learning and playing in English. It is just as natural for me to communicate in English as it is to communicate in my mother tongue. I would even go so far as to say that sometimes I find better expressions of my feelings in English than in my mother tongue. So when my people ask me the question, at first my answer is:

“Maybe you can immerse yourself in English, until it becomes second nature.”

 

But that is usually not the answer they want. They think I was privileged to have had a chance to be put in such an environment and do not believe they can create the same for themselves (though I beg to differ… there are so many ways you can keep yourself in contact with English, even if you do not actually live in an English-speaking region). So in my second answer, I try to give them some practical tips on where they find the language difficult:

“Maybe you can differentiate L’s and R’s like… and you can pronounce TH’s easier with… and when in doubt you can ignore A’s and The’s…”

 

But they are still not satisfied with my answers. Too many rules, and too many exceptions to remember… just give me the ones I really need, they tell me. And that is when it makes me start to wonder, what do they need English for to begin with? What do they want to communicate, and what do they envision themselves doing, once they are fluent in English? So my third answer ends up being:

“Maybe you need to find out what it is you need to say, or if there is any at all, and how much you want to say it. Then you will see better if I am the right person to ask.”

 

At this stage, most people think I am not willing and/or able to help… they tell me I would not understand the struggles they go through learning English because it came to me differently. And to them, I think “that’s what I’ve been trying to tell you!” But to those who are able to tell me exactly what they want to do once they are fluent in English, I have just one thing to say:

 

“If your heart is put into your words, it will find its way even if your English is broken. But I have a feeling you will become fluent after all, seeing how hard you try to get your words across.”

 

It is frustrating sometimes that I tell my answers fluently in my mother tongue yet my people do not receive it the way they are intended. That is when I am made to recognize that fluency is an advantage but not a necessity nor sufficiency. But I put my heart in my words, and I am hopeful they will find their way someday.

 

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “An advantage but not a necessity

  1. Interesting as always.
    I think becoming completely fluent in a language is difficult. In South Africa we were taught English and Afrikaans at school, but I only really learnt Afrikaans when I worked in a department where everyone spoke nothing else! I would still say I am not completely fluent. I use it almost every day, but I still sometimes run out of words. I can understand everything I hear, but don’t write much past basic communications.

    Like

    1. I agree with you, notewords – complete fluency in any language, even in mother tongue, is probably unattainable in the true sense. I suppose that’s why I get very cautious when I see my people teach our young minds to aim for fluency in English…
      You also have a good point in that languages come to life and stay alive only when they are put in constant use. Put in another way, I believe it’s never too late to learn a new language to make it come alive!
      But, after all I’ve said, I will be the first to admit that it’s a great advantage to be able to communicate in English – I get to talk to insightful people like you 😉

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s